Paleo/Primal Blueprint/Caveman Diet, Lifestyle
#171
FitDay Member
Join Date: Apr 2012
Posts: 1
I am also not losing on primal:(
I ate “paleo” for a year. Initially it worked well…I lost weight and felt great. However, I noticed I never felt full. I could eat a crapton of fatty meat and veggies and I still wanted to eat more. So, I started filling the gaps with nuts/coconut and attempted to further lower carbs (cutting out all fruit etc) This backfired in a huge way and left me with a seriously screwed up relationship with food. This isn’t per-se Paleo’s fault – however I am still bitter about the paleo high-fat insurgency. Primal (ala Sisson) is indeed low-carb high fat - PALEO is NOT. (Grain free just usually ends up lower carb than SAD) Primal will ONLY work if fat is incredibly satiating for you - you will eat less calories and lose weight “effortlessly.” This was NOT true for me....in fact for ME high fat meals are the least satiating of any maco-nutrient focus. High fat definitely works really well for some people - especially men. However, if it's NOT working please don't start randomly cutting more and more carbs – or telling everyone to further reduce their carbs. That's not the point of Paleo and you can seriously eff yourself up. The greatest tenet of paleo is "N=1." Don't listen to anyone but your own body. And if you don't keep loosing its not some insulin-BS - it means you're eating more calories than you're burning - period. If you HAVE to have a GURU then at least cross reference the facts before you treat them as Gospel:
Hunt.Gather.Love. | Melissa McEwen's on food anthropology, economics, and culture
Whole Health Source
My Carb Sane-Asylum
Perfect Health Diet
Archevore - Archevore Blog
Hunt.Gather.Love. | Melissa McEwen's on food anthropology, economics, and culture
Whole Health Source
My Carb Sane-Asylum
Perfect Health Diet
Archevore - Archevore Blog
#173
FitDay Member
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: San Francisco, CA
Posts: 576
And your point being what? That having high cholesterol means nothing? Or that having high cholesterol shouldn't be avoided? Or you'll just go ahead and continue eating and thinking like a caveman and not care about cholesterol?
Methinks you haven't thought this through either.
Methinks you haven't thought this through either.
LDL-C is actually a cholesterol carrier — the "LDL" is a molecular vehicle that gets the "C" to the injury site, where it acts kind of like a band-aid, sealing up the tear in the blood vessel wall. HDL, on the other hand, moves cholesterol in the reverse direction: peeling off the band-aid once the injury is healed and returning it to the liver for processing. So, I'd argue that cholesterol composition is more important than the actual value. Total triglycerides are probably a better marker of cardiac health than total cholesterol over the long term, with the caveat being when you're working on fat loss - because as you're losing fat your blood will be full of it.
Back to inflammation. One cause for inflammation is high blood sugar. By controlling carbohydrates in the diet, paleo reduces blood sugar levels and therefore controls inflammation well. As inflammation decreases, the body is able to heal more of its blood vessels and LDL levels drop, while HDL levels rise (to clear cholesterol from the bloodstream). Another cause of inflammation is high omega-6 fats, which actually form the signalling molecules that begin the inflammation response. A paleo-diet typically reduces these and incorporates more omega-3 fats, which soothe inflammation. It should also be noted that a few types of saturated fat also soothe inflammation. Examples are medium-chain acids like lauric and capric acids (found in coconut).
Finally, exercise and recovery account for the non-diet aspects of inflammation. All types of exercise tend to reduce systemic inflammation (cardio may exacerbate inflammation in joints associated with the activity, so don't forget to warm-up) BUT ONLY IF you provide for adequate recovery, including active rest such as walking, and plenty of sleep.
In relevance to this discussion, this means that trying to control your blood cholesterol directly through controlling consumption of saturated fat and dietary cholesterol doesn't really matter. What matters is indirect control over cholesterol type by reducing systemic inflammation. And in my experience paleo only helps.
I realize this might be a load of information so let me know if anything needs to be cleared up.
#175
FitDay Member
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: San Francisco, CA
Posts: 576
#176
Big congrats Nik!!! So when is the big day? If you don't mind you should share some pics!
Things have been good, I recently bought a motorcycle which is my biggest news. I need to get my diet in check as well, my exercising has been pretty good though. Thanks for asking.
Things have been good, I recently bought a motorcycle which is my biggest news. I need to get my diet in check as well, my exercising has been pretty good though. Thanks for asking.
#178
BIG CONGRATS NIK! Don't forget about us once you are in marital bliss . BTW very nice post regarding cholesterol. I especially liked your comment that LDL is an indicator, rather than a cause of arterial problems.
#179
Hi jukipants,
I am not an expert on paleo, but I have many gym rat buddies who swear by it. It seems to me that when combined with lots of weight bearing exercises (read: power lifting) it works really well. For those of us more into the endurance side of exercising like runners and bikers (the pedel kind, not the motorized kind) it isn't quite as effective because we run out of glycogen that fuels the muscles very quickly, well before the fat burning metabolism has a time to kick in.
That is just my observation over the years. I am kind of a psuedo-paleo person. I avoid all the refined stuff, but still indulge in whole grains, honey for tea and coffee, and the occassional powerbar type thing.
#180
FitDay Member
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: San Francisco, CA
Posts: 576
For those of us more into the endurance side of exercising like runners and bikers (the pedel kind, not the motorized kind) it isn't quite as effective because we run out of glycogen that fuels the muscles very quickly, well before the fat burning metabolism has a time to kick in.
I'm actually training for a half-marathon towards the end of the year and my secondary goal is to do it paleo! I'll probably go low-carb from a few months out to adapt and top off glycogen with sweet potatoes before the race, but I'm hoping to go all-out fat burning on race day.