Cycling Dropdown Options and Cal Burned
02-11-2013, 01:45 AM
#1
FitDay Premium Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2013
Posts: 3
Cycling Dropdown Options and Cal Burned
Hi Everyone
New to FitDay and just entering in my info, cycling is my primary exercise and I ride with groups with a pace of 20-28mph with an average of 175 miles a week.
The issue is the dropdown, FitDay offers a speed of “20+ not drafting” as my ride consists of pulling and drafting the option is incorrect.
In addition I use STRAVA to log my ride and Saturday I rode 64 miles with an average speed of 19.4mph STRAVA reports I burned 2169 cal (I do not have a Power Meter) FitDay calculates 3243 that quite a big difference
Any thoughts
Thanks
New to FitDay and just entering in my info, cycling is my primary exercise and I ride with groups with a pace of 20-28mph with an average of 175 miles a week.
The issue is the dropdown, FitDay offers a speed of “20+ not drafting” as my ride consists of pulling and drafting the option is incorrect.
In addition I use STRAVA to log my ride and Saturday I rode 64 miles with an average speed of 19.4mph STRAVA reports I burned 2169 cal (I do not have a Power Meter) FitDay calculates 3243 that quite a big difference
Any thoughts
Thanks
02-11-2013, 07:21 PM
#2
FitDay Member
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Saint Paul, MN
Posts: 119
Hi Brightonuk,
I ride about the same mileage each week, but not quite as fast as you! I would strongly suggest using the numbers your HRM spits out over anything on Strava or Fitday. As far as recording on Fitday, you kind of have two options: 1.) you can log time and miles and pay no attention to the calories (since you already use Strava it might be best to go with the next option), or 2.) you can make the activity type/time match what your HRM says you burned. So, for example you could enter in a lower speed from the drop down or use the 20+ mph, but less time so that the number of calories burned is more realistic.
I kind of do a combination of the two. My average is about 17mph when I'm out on my own, so I enter it as "12-13mph, leisure" (so about 1-2 "levels" below my actual activity) to get the calories more accurate. Then I record the actual number of miles and the time it took. That way the calorie burn FD reports is sort of in the ballpark.
It really depends on what your goals are. If you're trying to drop a bunch of weight before race season, logging calories as accurately as possible on FD is your best bet. Heck, you could even use a completely different activity (like karate or square dancing), just so your calorie burn is accurate. If (like me) you are more in a maintenance phase you probably shouldn't worry if the count is off a bit and just focus on logging miles and time. At best FD is just an estimation of what you actually did. Use your other tools to make the math work out. Also, when in doubt underestimate your activity (so in this case go with the numbers Strava gives) and overestimate your food intake -- if you're trying to drop a few pounds off your bike for cheap, that is the best way!!
Happy trails,
S. Doom
I ride about the same mileage each week, but not quite as fast as you! I would strongly suggest using the numbers your HRM spits out over anything on Strava or Fitday. As far as recording on Fitday, you kind of have two options: 1.) you can log time and miles and pay no attention to the calories (since you already use Strava it might be best to go with the next option), or 2.) you can make the activity type/time match what your HRM says you burned. So, for example you could enter in a lower speed from the drop down or use the 20+ mph, but less time so that the number of calories burned is more realistic.
I kind of do a combination of the two. My average is about 17mph when I'm out on my own, so I enter it as "12-13mph, leisure" (so about 1-2 "levels" below my actual activity) to get the calories more accurate. Then I record the actual number of miles and the time it took. That way the calorie burn FD reports is sort of in the ballpark.
It really depends on what your goals are. If you're trying to drop a bunch of weight before race season, logging calories as accurately as possible on FD is your best bet. Heck, you could even use a completely different activity (like karate or square dancing), just so your calorie burn is accurate. If (like me) you are more in a maintenance phase you probably shouldn't worry if the count is off a bit and just focus on logging miles and time. At best FD is just an estimation of what you actually did. Use your other tools to make the math work out. Also, when in doubt underestimate your activity (so in this case go with the numbers Strava gives) and overestimate your food intake -- if you're trying to drop a few pounds off your bike for cheap, that is the best way!!
Happy trails,
S. Doom
