But I want more than calories
Both of those recipe sites are fine for calories, but the nutritional data is quite limited. What makes Fitday better than the others (for me) is that it tracks a wide range of nutrients. Entering a soup recipe of mine into caloriecount gave me only:
Nothing about magnesium, zinc, selenium, etc.
I'd love to find a recipe site that includes all the nutrient data that Fitday does. For now, I'll stick to doing them by hand in Fitday.